Your first employee: how to set up payroll for small business
Hired your first employee and not sure how to set up payroll for small business? Here it is step by step: which registrations you need, which documents to sign on day one, what to withhold from wages, which forms to file and when, and how to avoid mistakes in your first pay runs.
We set up payroll from scratch: register you as an employer with the state, run the first paycheck and file 941, 940 and W-2 on time.
Send a request — it’s free More about this service Call: +1 (929) 340-2427 Consultation from $120Your first employee is not just a new line in your expenses but a new role: you become an employer. From now on you withhold taxes from every paycheck, pay your own share, file returns with the IRS and the state, and keep employment records. Here is how to set up payroll for a small business from scratch, with the forms, 2026 rates and deadlines.
First, check: employee or contractor
Payroll is for employees. If a person runs their own business, decides how to do the work and bears their own expenses, they may be a contractor; then a W-9 and a year-end 1099-NEC are enough. Status is determined by the facts, not the contract; see W-2 vs 1099. The rest of this article is about employees.
Step 1. EIN and employer registration with the state
An EIN (Employer Identification Number) is your employer number with the IRS; you cannot hire without one. It is free and issued immediately online if the business was formed in the US and the responsible party has an SSN or ITIN. Most LLCs already have one; a sole proprietor working under an SSN needs to apply.
With the state, you usually need two registrations:
- a state withholding account for state income tax, in states that have one;
- state unemployment insurance (SUI), which exists in every state; the state assigns a new-employer rate itself.
Registration in each state is a separate procedure; we do it for $120 per state. If an employee works remotely from another state, you generally register where the employee works.
Every new employee must also be reported to the state's new hire registry. The state sets the deadline, usually within 20 days of the hire date.
Step 2. Day-one documents: W-4 and I-9
- Form W-4 (Employee's Withholding Certificate): the employee reports filing status, dependents and other details used to figure federal withholding. You need it before the first paycheck. If the employee does not provide one, the IRS says to withhold as if they were single with no adjustments. Some states have their own form for state tax.
- Form I-9 (Employment Eligibility Verification): proof of the right to work in the US. It is a USCIS form, but the IRS requires it for every employee, citizen or not. The employee completes their section; you review the documents and complete yours within 3 business days of the first day of work. Keep it on file; it is not sent anywhere.
- The employee's SSN. The name and Social Security number are needed for the W-2; an ITIN cannot replace an SSN for employment.
Keep these documents with the rest of your payroll records for at least 4 years.
Step 3. Pay frequency
The most common choices are biweekly (every two weeks, 26 paychecks a year) and semimonthly (twice a month, 24 paychecks). The minimum frequency is usually set by state law, so "once a quarter" will not work. Once chosen, do not change the schedule without a reason: deposit due dates depend on the pay date.
Step 4. What is withheld from wages and what the employer pays
| Tax | Withheld from the employee | Paid by the employer |
|---|---|---|
| Federal income tax | per the W-4 and IRS tables (Publication 15-T) | — |
| Social Security | 6.2% on wages up to $184,500 in 2026 | 6.2% |
| Medicare | 1.45% with no cap, plus 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax on wages over $200,000 for the year | 1.45% |
| FUTA (federal unemployment) | — | 6.0% on the first $7,000 of wages; a credit of up to 5.4% for state contributions paid on time, so usually 0.6% net |
| State income tax | per state rules | — |
| State unemployment insurance (SUI) | generally none | at the state's rate on part of the wages |
Example: on a $4,000 monthly salary, $248 of Social Security and $58 of Medicare are withheld, plus income tax per the W-4; the company pays the same $248 and $58 on top, plus FUTA and state contributions.
Withheld taxes and the employer share go to the IRS as deposits, electronically only, through EFTPS or the IRS business tax account. In the first year an employer is a monthly depositor: the deposit for a month is due by the 15th of the next month. If less than $2,500 accumulates in a quarter, the tax can be paid with the quarterly return. At $100,000 or more in a day, the deposit is due the next business day; hardly relevant for a first employee, but worth knowing.
Step 5. Forms and deadlines: 941, 940, W-2
| Form | What it is | Due date |
|---|---|---|
| Form 941 | quarterly report of wages, withholding, Social Security and Medicare | April 30, July 31, October 31, January 31; 10 more days if deposits were on time |
| Form 944 | annual report instead of 941 for employers with up to $1,000 in taxes a year, only if the IRS notified you in writing | January 31 |
| Form 940 | annual FUTA return | January 31 (February 10 if deposits were on time); the tax itself is deposited quarterly once the liability exceeds $500 |
| W-2 and W-3 | annual report for each employee: copies to the employee and to the Social Security Administration | January 31; for 2026, by February 1, 2027, because January 31 falls on a Sunday |
| State returns | withholding and unemployment insurance | on the state's schedule, usually quarterly |
If a due date falls on a weekend or holiday, it moves to the next business day.
State insurance
Besides taxes, an employer has insurance obligations at the state level:
- Workers' compensation, insurance against workplace injuries. In most states it is mandatory from the first employee and is bought from an insurer or a state fund.
- Disability and paid family leave. Some states, such as New York, New Jersey and California, have mandatory programs with employer or employee contributions.
Requirements vary by state, so we check this separately when setting up payroll.
First-payroll mistakes
- Treating an employee as a contractor. The most expensive one: payroll taxes, interest and penalties for all the years.
- Paying wages before registering with the state. The first state returns are then late, with a penalty.
- Not completing the I-9, or completing it late. The form is simple, but it is checked separately from taxes.
- Withholding tax and not sending it to the IRS. Withheld taxes are the employee's money held in trust. The IRS can collect the full unpaid amount personally from the owner or manager (trust fund recovery penalty), even if the business has closed.
- Forgetting FUTA and Form 940. The tax is small, but the form is annual, and people remember it when the letter arrives.
- Paying under the table. The taxes do not go away, and there is no way to support wage expenses without payroll.
- Not recording payroll in the books. Wages, employer taxes and deposits must match the bank statements, or the business return will be wrong. It is easier when payroll and bookkeeping are handled together.
What payroll costs
From our price list:
- payroll setup: a one-time $250 for registrations, the pay schedule and adding employees;
- employer registration with the state: $120 per state;
- monthly service: from $150 a month for up to 3 employees, $20 a month for each additional one; it includes pay runs, deposits, Forms 941 and 940, state returns and W-2s at year end;
- an off-cycle pay run is $40, a second state is $50 a month, and a 1099-NEC for a contractor is $30.
Details are on our payroll service page. If you own an S corp and are its only employee, you need to put yourself on payroll too: tax is withheld from your salary, while distributions may call for estimated tax.
How to set up payroll for small business: a short checklist
- Check that the business has an EIN and register as an employer with the state before the first paycheck.
- Prepare the W-4 and I-9 for your employee and set the first pay date.
- Choose a pay schedule and set up a calendar of deposits and returns: the 15th, quarter end, January 31.
- Set withheld taxes aside from your operating cash, so there is always money for the deposit.
Setting up payroll is not hard if everything is done in order before the first paycheck rather than after. We will register you as an employer, run the first paycheck and take the filings off your hands. Book a consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Can I pay an employee in cash without payroll?
No. The method of payment does not change your obligations: taxes still have to be withheld from wages, the employer share paid and the returns filed. Cash without payroll means unpaid taxes, penalties and no way to support the wage expense on the business return.
I own an S corp and I am its only employee. Do I need payroll too?
Yes. An S corp owner who works in the business receives a reasonable salary through payroll with taxes withheld, and the rest of the profit as distributions. Forms 941, 940 and W-2 are filed the same way as for any employee.
My employee has not given me a W-4. How do I figure withholding?
The IRS says to withhold federal income tax as if the employee filled out the W-4 as single with no adjustments. Once the form arrives, withholding is updated starting with the next payroll period.
I missed a tax deposit. What should I do?
Make it as soon as possible: the failure-to-deposit penalty grows with the number of days late, from 2% for up to 5 days late, 5% for up to 15 days and 10% beyond that, to 15% after an IRS notice. If your returns were filed and your taxes deposited on time for the previous 12 quarters, then starting with 2026 returns the IRS does not charge this penalty at all: this is the Automatic Exemption from Penalty (AEP). Without a clean record, you can ask for the penalty to be removed for reasonable cause.
No wages were paid this quarter. Do I still file Form 941?
Yes. The IRS requires a Form 941 for every quarter, even with no taxes to report, until you file a final return. If you have stopped paying wages for good, check the final-return box on your last Form 941 and enter the date of the last wage payment.
This article is for general information and does not replace advice on your specific situation.
