Payroll Setup & Processing

Employee or contractor: W-2 vs 1099-NEC

Hiring your first helper and not sure whether to put them on payroll or pay them on a 1099? Here is how the IRS tells an employee from a contractor, which taxes and forms each option requires, and what a mistake can cost.

Updated 10 min readNova Tax · reviewed by an Enrolled Agent

As a business grows, sooner or later the question comes up: should a new person be hired as an employee and paid wages on a W-2, or brought on as a contractor who gets a Form 1099-NEC at the end of the year? It can look like a matter of preference, but it is not. The IRS decides status based on the facts, not the contract, and getting it wrong is expensive: back taxes, interest and penalties. Below we cover how to tell an employee from a contractor, which taxes and forms each option requires, and the deadlines a business faces in early 2027.

Employee vs. contractor: the difference

An employee works in your business under your direction. You pay them through payroll, withhold taxes, pay your own share of payroll taxes and give them a Form W-2 in January.

An independent contractor runs their own business and provides a service to you. This can be a sole proprietor (an individual working for themselves), a single-member LLC (an LLC with one owner) or another company. You do not withhold taxes for them: they pay on their own, including through quarterly estimated payments. If your payments for the year reach the threshold, you give them a Form 1099-NEC.

Employee (W-2) Contractor (1099-NEC)
Who decides how the work is done the business the worker
Tax withholding the business withholds income tax, Social Security and Medicare none; the worker pays on their own
Business payroll taxes 7.65% of wages + FUTA and state taxes none
Form from the worker at hiring Form W-4 (and I-9) Form W-9
Year-end form W-2 1099-NEC, if payments are $2,000 or more
Tools and expenses usually paid by the business usually paid by the worker
Benefits (paid time off, insurance) may be offered none

How the IRS decides: three categories of evidence

There is no single formula. The IRS applies the common-law rules and looks at how much control the business has over the work and how independent the worker is. The factors fall into three categories, and no single factor settles the question on its own: the IRS weighs the whole picture.

Behavioral control

Does the business decide how the work is done, or only what the end result should be? Signs of an employee: you set the schedule and place of work and the order of tasks, train the person in your methods, and review not only the result but the process. A contractor is usually given a task and judged on the result, and decides how to get there on their own.

Financial control

Who controls the business side of the job? Signs of a contractor: the worker invests in their own tools and equipment, covers their own unreimbursed expenses, can make a profit or a loss, works for other clients too and invoices by the project. An employee is usually paid for time, by the hour, by the week or as a fixed salary, and has expenses reimbursed.

Relationship of the parties

What does the contract say, and how do the parties actually behave? Are there employee-type benefits such as paid time off, health insurance or a retirement plan? Is the relationship a one-off or ongoing with no end date? If the work is permanent and a key part of your business, that points toward employee status.

An "independent contractor agreement" does not settle anything by itself. If in practice the person works as an employee, the IRS will treat them as an employee.

When in doubt: Form SS-8

Either the business or the worker can file Form SS-8 with the IRS and ask it to determine the status. It is the official route, but not a fast one: the IRS warns that a determination can take at least six months. For more on the rules, see the IRS page on independent contractors.

State rules can be stricter

The federal test is not the only one. States have their own rules for state tax, unemployment insurance and labor law, and they can be tougher.

The best-known example is California's ABC test. There, a worker is considered an employee unless the business proves all three conditions:

  1. A: the worker is free from the business's control and direction in performing the work, both under the contract and in fact;
  2. B: the work is outside the usual course of the business;
  3. C: the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation or business of the same kind.

For example, if a beauty salon brings in a nail technician to do manicures for the salon's clients, condition B is already in question, since that is the salon's core business. Similar tests apply in some other states, so it is worth checking your state's rules before you hire.

What you need when you hire an employee (W-2)

An employee means regular payroll: paying wages with taxes withheld. From each paycheck you withhold:

  • federal income tax, based on Form W-4;
  • Social Security, 6.2% (in 2026, on wages up to $184,500);
  • Medicare, 1.45% of all wages, plus an additional 0.9% on wages over $200,000;
  • state and local taxes, if any.

On top of that, the business pays its own share, the same 6.2% and 1.45%, plus FUTA, the federal unemployment tax: 6% of the first $7,000 of each employee's wages, though if you pay your state unemployment tax on time, a credit brings the rate down to 0.6%. Withheld and employer taxes have to be deposited on schedule and reported quarterly on Form 941, and FUTA once a year on Form 940.

In January you give the employee a W-2 and file it with the Social Security Administration. The deadline is January 31; if that falls on a weekend, it moves to the next business day, so for 2026 it is February 1, 2027.

All of this is easier to hand off to professionals: we set up and run payroll for small businesses, starting from a single employee.

What you need when you work with a contractor (1099-NEC)

Form W-9 before the first payment

Ask the contractor to fill out Form W-9, which gives their name, business type and taxpayer identification number (SSN or EIN). Do this before the first payment: getting the form later is harder.

If the contractor does not provide a taxpayer ID, you may need to apply backup withholding: 24% of payments, which you send to the IRS.

The 1099-NEC threshold: $2,000 starting in 2026

Previously, a 1099-NEC was required if you paid a contractor $600 or more during the year. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act raised the threshold: for payments made in 2026 and later it is $2,000 per recipient per year. Starting in 2027, the amount may be adjusted for inflation.

Keep in mind that payments to the same worker add up over the year. Four payments of $600 come to $2,400, so the form is required. And the contractor must report their income on their return even if they never received a form.

As a rule, a 1099-NEC is not issued to corporations (including LLCs that elected S-corp or C-corp status), and payments made by card or through payment apps are not reported on it, since the payment processors report them. There are exceptions, such as legal services, so it is worth collecting a W-9 from everyone.

The 1099-NEC deadline for 2026

The form has to be both furnished to the contractor and filed with the IRS by January 31. In 2027, January 31 is a Sunday, so the deadline for 2026 payments is February 1, 2027. As a rule, there is no extension for Form 1099-NEC. If you have 10 or more information returns in total (1099s, W-2s and others), you must file them electronically.

Late filing penalties

The penalty applies per form and grows with the delay. For forms filed in 2026, it was $60 if filed within 30 days after the deadline, $130 if filed by August 1, and $340 if filed later or not at all. For intentional disregard, it starts at $680 per form. The amounts are adjusted every year, and the same penalty applies separately for failing to furnish a copy to the recipient.

Misclassification: what a mistake costs

Misclassification means classifying a worker incorrectly, usually treating an employee as a contractor. If the business had no reasonable basis for doing so, the IRS can collect the payroll taxes for that person, both the employer's share and the amount that should have been withheld, plus interest and penalties. Add to that state taxes, unemployment insurance and possible labor claims.

What can be done:

  • Section 530 relief: relief from the taxes if the business had a reasonable basis for treating the worker as a contractor, filed all the required 1099s and treated all workers in similar roles consistently;
  • Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (VCSP): a voluntary program in which the business reclassifies workers as employees going forward and gets partial relief from taxes for past periods (filed on Form 8952).

A worker who believes they were classified incorrectly can file Form SS-8 and report the unpaid Social Security and Medicare on Form 8919. If you work on a 1099 yourself, remember that you pay self-employment tax and income tax on your own; see our page for the self-employed.

Checklist before you hire

  1. Describe how the work will be organized: who sets the schedule, whose tools are used, whether it is a one-off project or an ongoing role.
  2. Check the status against the three IRS categories and your state's rules.
  3. For a contractor: get a W-9 before the first payment and track payments to each worker.
  4. For an employee: get a W-4 and I-9, register with your state as an employer and set up payroll before the first paycheck.
  5. Put February 1, 2027 on your calendar: the deadline for 2026 Forms W-2 and 1099-NEC.
  6. If your business is not set up yet or has no EIN, start with company registration.

Every situation is different, and this article is general information only. If you are unsure how to classify a worker, book a consultation: we will review your situation and help you get it right from the first payment.

Frequently asked questions

Can we simply agree with a worker that they will be paid on a 1099?

No. Status is not set by the contract or by what the parties want, but by how the work is actually done: who controls the process, who bears the expenses and how permanent the relationship is. If in practice the person works as an employee, an independent contractor agreement will not protect the business from back payroll taxes.

We paid a contractor $1,500 for 2026. Do we need to file Form 1099-NEC?

For payments made in 2026, the 1099-NEC threshold is $2,000 per recipient per year, so the form is not required in this case. The contractor still has to report this income on their return, and the business should keep the W-9 and payment records.

I work on a 1099, but I think I am really an employee. What can I do?

You can file Form SS-8 with the IRS and ask it to determine your status. A decision can take six months or longer. If you are found to be an employee, you report your share of Social Security and Medicare that the employer did not withhold on Form 8919.

Can the owner of a single-member LLC pay themselves on a W-2?

Usually not: the profit of such an LLC is reported on the owner's personal return, and the owner does not pay themselves a salary. A W-2 salary for the owner comes into play if the LLC has elected to be taxed as an S-corp or C-corp.

This article is for general information and does not replace advice on your specific situation.

Keep reading